Retaining Walls: Natural Stone vs. Blocks

16 Apr Retaining Walls: Natural Stone vs. Blocks

Whether you are building a retaining wall or having one installed for you, the materials used to build the wall need to be the best. There are a wide variety of blocks and natural stone to use. We’re going to cover some of the major differences (pros/cons basically) of each type of retaining wall for Minnesota. Learn more about retaining walls at our page. 

A retaining wall is an integral part of any sloped yard. It allows a homeowner to have a garden, build a beautiful patio, control rain water drainage, have some flat space for grass, or any other number of uses.

However, the real point of a retaining wall is to hold back soil. Soil is heavy. Not a huge enlightening statement there but it’s important to remember that fact while you choose the materials for you retaining wall. The amount of force pushing on the wall can very drastically depending on the length and height of the wall you’re building.

Retaining Wall Blocks

What are they: These are the most popular materials used for a retaining wall. They’re the poured concrete blocks that you see pretty much everywhere. They come in two different sizes, a smaller one for small walls (about 12″ wide and 4″ tall and 25 lbs). They’re best used for plant beds and terraces or shorter length walls. They also make larger blocks for long and/or tall walls (about 18″ wide and 6″ tall and 50 lbs). If you’re doing anything more than a small wall or a plant bed, use these large blocks. The blocks also come in solid blocks (weigh more, solid concrete) and hollow blocks (fill with gravel after stacking).

Stay-Together-ness: Retaining blocks use a variety of different technologies to stay together and hold back the weight.

  • The most common method is the lip method where the back end of the retaining wall block has a lip hanging off which locks it behind the block beneath it. This is a tried and true method but does not allow for straight faced walls like in an outdoor living space. The lip is always set so you cannot adjust the set back.
  • The other common method for holding the wall together is the pin system. The blocks have holes in them where the installer uses fiberglass or tough plastic pins to anchor the blocks together. The advantages to this system is that you can control the set back so straight walls are possible. However, the holes are pre-drilled so if they get filled with dirt, it makes it really hard. Corners are also tough.

Ease of Use: Blocks are extremely easy to use. The weight of the blocks can be a minor deterrence for some people but the stacking systems are reliable and easy to understand.

Advantages: Easy to learn how to use. Cheaper. Wide variety of color choices. Different stacking methods. Reliable for keeping dirt contained.

Limitations: Corners and decorative walls are harder to obtain and need special pieces or to cut in half. Curves are difficult. Can be extremely heavy and labor intensive. Not as unique.

IMG_0761

Natural Stone Retaining Wall

What are they: Natural stone pieces like boulders are stacked to create a wall. There are different natural stone materials available. Boulder walls are a popular option. You stack very large (and very heavy) boulders in a line. Dirt is stopped from coming through the gaps using landscape fabric. There are also Rubble Walls. These walls are a random assortment of boulders and rocks to create a unique wall at every single property. You can use gravel to fill in the cracks behind the rocks. Cut Stone are the other type of natural stone walls. Stone is cut down to thinner pieces which are then stacked on top of each other. Every stone is cut differently so the wall has a unique, natural look.

Stay-Together-ness: No mortar or locking systems needed here. Just patience and heavy equipment or big muscles. When building these types of walls, you pick out each individual rock or boulder to fit in spot needed. This is isn’t so bad with a cut rock wall where each piece isn’t that expensive, but it can be hard when moving around 80+ lb boulders.

Ease of Use: Takes a very creative touch to find an individual stone that looks good AND fits in the spot that’s needed. As touched on before, the rocks and boulders are really heavy. Each row has to be completely built up and filled in as you go so this is a time consuming, patience testing situation.

Advantages: Unique. More natural look. Much more varied color and design. Can fit any situation (wall height or length).

Limitations: More labor intensive because boulders/rocks are heavy. More expensive. Corners are tough. Time consuming to find the correct rock or boulder for the right spot.

Really Important Retaining Wall Details

Put down a good base

Regularly old dirt expands and contracts with the extreme weather in Minnesota and other northern climates. If your retaining wall is built on the ground, the base layer will move up and down with the contracting and expanding of the dirt. This causes the wall to become unstable and fail within 2-3 years. So put down a good layer of base material (class 5 preferably). The different sizes of rock and gravel almost form a concrete layer at the bottom of the wall that resists expansion and contraction and keeps your wall stable for years to come!

Level the bottom layer (and every layer)

The wall should be extremely stable to hold back all that dirt. A wall that’s not level is much more susceptible to push back and failure. The base layer is absolutely the most important layer to get level. The rest of the layers rest on that one so it’s absolutely crucial. For a block wall, we use a small level and get every individual block level, then use a 36″ level to check long rows.

Have good drainage!!!

Many retaining walls fail because water rushes down the back side of the wall, making the dirt weigh more and push out on the wall. Unless it’s a wall that’s less than 30″ tall, you need to have gravel on the entire back of the wall to allow water to run down the back of the wall so it does not push. Also, include a drainage tube with fabric around it at the base of the wall so any water that gets to the bottom, drains away.

Retaining Wall Construction Design Minneapolis MN

More Retaining Wall Resources